Joseph D'Onofrio

as Dave Iacovetti Jr

as Dominick Cuchie 'Big Sally'

as Al Capone

as Dippy

as Vito

as Rocco Rosano

as Detective Wayne

as Robber

as Sal Carmine

as Mr. Fiorenza

as The Producer

as Franky

as Bootsy

as Donny The Baker

as Bruno

as Joey G

as Tony Vespa

as Doctor Bob

as Andy Roma

as Joseph

as Rocco

as Father Scott

as Vinny Skins

as Raymond Paladino

as Matty

as Blue Collar Mafia

as Angelo

as Frankie

as Joey

as Security Guard

as Roland

as Waiter

as Town car driver

as Officer Lemon

as New York Mets Fan #1

as John (as Joe D'Onofrio)

as Marc (as Joe D'Onofrio)

as Random Man on Street

as Nico

as Freddy

as Bloodied Patron

as Louie Downtown

as Dave

as Mugger

as Sal

as Rigazzi Gunman

as Opinionated Cop

as Vinny

as Theo

as Cousin Vinny

as Mailman

as Lawrence

as A Pallbearer

as Sully

as Slick (Age 17)

as Mike

as Sal

as Delivery Person

as Patty

as John Rotelli

as Young Tommy

as Larry

as Tony Spilotro